Fix-and-flip margins tighten in Q3 as prices dip and costs rise
The fix-and-flip market in the United States showed signs of weakening during the third quarter of the year, influenced by mortgage rates exceeding 7%, which dampened buyer interest. Concurrently, a decline in home prices and rising labor costs have pressured the profit margins of investors, as highlighted in a recent survey conducted by Kiavi and John Burns Research and Consulting.
The Burns + Kiavi Fix and Flip Market Index registered a score of 53 for the third quarter, a decrease from 59 in the previous quarter and 56 a year earlier. This marks the lowest reading for the index, which evaluates market conditions on a scale ranging from 0 to 100, in nearly four years. Scores below 50 indicate a contraction in the market, while those above 50 suggest expansion. The report, set to be released in November 2026, is based on a proprietary quarterly survey involving around 280 fix-and-flip investors.
In terms of outlook, only 23% of investors anticipate strong sales over the next six months, representing the lowest level of optimism in four years. Conversely, 19% expect poor sales, the highest proportion since the fourth quarter of 2022. This slowdown is impacting both large and small investors, with large flippers—defined as those who have bought or sold at least eight homes in the last 18 months—reporting tougher market conditions than their smaller counterparts for the first time since the third quarter of 2022.
The increase in mortgage rates has diminished the pricing power of investors, with 40% of flippers indicating that home sale prices in their areas have fallen compared to a year ago. This contrasts with only 16% who noted an increase in prices, while 36% reported that prices remained stable. The Southwest region experienced the highest percentage of flippers reporting lower prices at 67%, followed by Southern California at 50%. In Texas and the Southeast, 47% reported declining prices, and 44% of respondents in Florida shared similar sentiments.
Approximately 20% of flippers revealed they were selling homes for prices below their initial after-repair value estimates, nearing the highest level recorded by the survey since 2021. The survey also identified that immigration enforcement is impacting the availability and costs of renovation labor. Forty-one percent of flippers stated that increased immigration enforcement has negatively affected their labor force, an increase from 33% in the second quarter of 2025.
Respondents reported challenges in finding workers, rising labor costs, and extended project timelines. These issues were particularly significant in Florida and the Southeast, although difficulties were noted in other regions as well.
On a more positive note, the increase in available inventory is providing additional opportunities for investors. A notable 24% of flippers indicated that competition for deals was lower than usual, marking the highest percentage recorded in the survey's history. Despite this increased availability, investors are still cautious about their purchasing decisions, with the average flipper aiming for a maximum purchase price of 67% of a property's after-repair value, a slight decrease from the previous quarter.
Renovation costs also exhibited considerable regional variation. The national average cost for flipping a home was reported at $72,000 in the third quarter, with costs soaring to $133,000 in Southern California and $86,000 in the Northeast. In contrast, the Southeast and Texas reported lower costs of $47,000 and $46,000, respectively.
The findings from the survey suggest ongoing challenges for investors due to elevated financing costs, diminished buyer demand, and labor constraints, all of which complicate project profitability. Consequently, John Burns advised flippers to exercise caution when acquiring properties and to ensure adequate margins to accommodate potential price declines and increased labor costs. Furthermore, lenders were encouraged to assess properties based on anticipated sale prices at the time of sale, rather than relying solely on recently completed comparable sales, which may lag in a declining market.